Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

How A Man Feels in Battle

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • How A Man Feels in Battle

    I was looking for something else yesterday and came across this article from the April 16, 1863 Gallipolis Journal – Gallipolis, Ohio. It kind of speaks for itself.

    “How a Man Feels in Battle. – There can be nothing more puzzling than the analysis of one’s feelings on a battle-field. You cannot describe them satisfactorily to yourself and others. – To march steadily up to the mouths of a hundred cannon, while they pour out fire and smoke and shot and shell in a storm that mows the men like grass is horrible beyond description – appaling. It is absurd to say a man can do it without fear. During Hancock’s charge at Fredericksburg, for a long distance the slope was swept by such a hurricane of death that we thought every step would be our last, and I am willing to say, for one, that I was pretty badly scared. Whatever may be said about ‘getting used to it,’ old soldiers secretly dred a battle equally with new ones. But the most difficult thing to stand up under is the suspense while waiting, as we waited at Fredericksburg, drawn up in line of battle on the edge of the field, watching the column of smoke, where horses and men and colors go down in confusion, where all sounds are lost in the screaming of shells, the cracking of musketry, the thunder of artillery, and knowing that our turn comes next, expecting each moment the word ‘Forward.’ It brings a strange kind of relief when ‘forward’ comes. You move mechanically with the rest. Once fairly in for it, your sensibilities are strangely blunted – you care comparatively nothing about the sights that shocked you at first – men torn to pieces by cannon shot become a matter of course. At such a time there come a latent sustenance from within us, or above us, which no man anticipates who has not been in such a place before, and which most men pass through life without knowing anything about.”

    Submitted by:
    Linda Trent
    lindatrent@zoomnet.net
    Last edited by LindaTrent; 10-04-2006, 10:19 AM. Reason: Apparently my sig line didn't work.
    Linda Trent
    [email]linda_trent@att.net[/email]

    “It ain’t what you know that gets you into trouble.
    It’s what you know that just ain’t so.” Mark Twain.

  • #2
    Re: How A Man Feels in Battle

    The books "Embattled Courage" and "The Union Soldier in Battle: Enduring the Ordeal of Combat" (the latter by Earl J. Hess) are both good starting points to further explore this topic. It should be of great interest to reenactors.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: How A Man Feels in Battle

      It brings a strange kind of relief the word, foward
      I myself experience a little anxiety when waiting to move foward, or marching some distance towards the sound of battle, and for me it is a little relief when you get to the fight. I can't imagine what it must have really been like to wait for real combat.
      Tyler Underwood
      Moderator
      Pawleys Island #409 AFM
      Governor Guards, WIG

      Click here for the AC rules.

      The search function located in the upper right corner of the screen is your friend.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: How A Man Feels in Battle

        While not on par with what the Original Boys felt with the marching to the sound of the guns, and waiting to go in, I can only say for certain what I felt.

        While being a FOBer, I can say that I was VERY ALERT for a year, and that indeed the flutterbyes in the breadbasket got really excited everytime we left the gate. I can only guess that it was the same for the Boys of '61-65. Constant Fear, releived only by boredom, and gallows and off color humor.
        Robert W. Hughes
        Co A, 2nd Georgia Sharpshooters/64th Illinois Inf.
        Thrasher Mess
        Operation Iraqi Freedom II 2004-2005
        ENG Brigade, 1st Cavalry Div. "1st Team!"
        Iraq & Afghanistan Veterans of America

        Then I heard the voice of the Lord saying, "Whom shall I send? And who will go for us?"
        And I said "Here I am. Send me!" Isaiah 6:8

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: How A Man Feels in Battle

          I posted something similar to the following elsewhere, when Linda read me that quote originally.

          Ironically, what the author says, is one reason I'm not attracted to the sensation of "powder burning" itself, and enjoy other aspects of reenacting more.

          If I think of it as just firing blanks in a hobby, it seems silly.

          If I try to take it seriously and pretend I'm "really there," really trying to kill people or risk being killed, it turns out just like he says, "Once fairly in for it, your sensibilities are strangely blunted - you care comparatively nothing about the sights..." I've not faced real combat, but from other real-life circumstances, I know what he's talking about. It seems silly to invest so much time and effort just to spend an hour or two doing something that feels, internally, as boring as mowing the lawn.

          So for me, the parts before and afterward, or with no battle at all, are of most interest, if I want a chance at suspending disbelief and getting that "magic moment." Ironically, those are the times when a lot of reenactors are less interested in having a period experience, because they're waiting to put on their "A game" for the battle.

          Hank Trent
          hanktrent@voyager.net
          Hank Trent

          Comment

          Working...
          X