Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Why did they fight?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Why did they fight?

    Every now and then the question comes up of why did the American Civil War soldier answer the call of duty in the first place. There are of course the generic answers of not wanting to be left out, thought it would be an adventure, was ashamed not to go, etc. But to be able to pin point that defining moment, and to know when, where, and why is priceless. Below is a section from the memoirs of Private Jefferson Moses, Company G, 93rd Illinois Volunteers. Here we get a chance to see just what would make a person go off to war.

    “The fall before I inlisted or the year the war broke out no one could get me to go to the army. In the fall of 1861 we was husking corn one noon. An old pedler came to our house. He had a linement he sold. Said it was so good for sore hands. Father told him to come eat dinner with us and while we ware eating they talked war. My I trembled to hear them talk. Father would say this war won't last only a short time for the south had no food or war material. The old man said don't you believe it. They have plenty. Father said they raised nothing but cotton. No wheat or corn and they depended on the north for food. The old man said you will find out it will be a long war and your boy may go to war yet before the thing ends. My how I trembled. I was an awful coward. Nothing could get me to inlist and go to war. I was then in my 18th year and in reading history where they drafted men and put them in the front ranks to keep them from running away. I think if I was put in the front rank I would study how to get out.
    Well in the spring of 1862 the Battle of Shilow was fought and a numbers of boys were killed and sent home. I was in Freeport (Illinois) one day and a Captain of some regiment was sent home dead. He laid in state up in one of the churches. I went up and went along with the people and marched in the churh to see him laying in his coffin. I had never before seen a soldier of the United States.
    I got home and told pa and ma I wanted to go to war. I never felt so in my life. I just felt a great duty that I never before thought of. I stayed at home thro the summer. But in August their was a rally at the high school building in Cedarville. I was there and got the fever. To a finish that evening they recruited for a company. A man from Orangeville was recruiting for a company. This was on the 11th of August and all my comrads or associates inlisted. That is I did want to go. But I did not want to go till I had the consent of father and mother. The first thing they asked me when I got home was did you inlist. No I did not but do give your consent and let me go. All the rest of the boys have inlisted and I want to go along. Finely father said you have our consent to go and may gods blessing go with you. My dear mother stood beside me with her hands to her face crying to most break my heart. Oh the sad moment. I got my breakfast. Went to Cedarville. Put my name on the list. Was then sworn in the army to serve three years as during the war. I was now a United States soldier and was redy to go any time.”


    The link to the web page containing this and a lot more info on Jefferson Moses has been posted here before, but that was some time ago so here it is again for those of you who may have missed it or have never seen it. http://www.ioweb.com/civilwar/

  • #2
    Re: Why did they fight?

    All of my relatives who fought, and my wifes relatives, were from East and Middle Tennessee. I had two on each side from upper East Tennessee. One was with the 16th Georgia and I believe he must have been conscripted by Longstreet after he made his way north after the Battle of Fort Sanders. His records differ on his enlistment date, but as far as I know he did not enlist at the beginning of the war. One in the 29th Tennessee may have joined a Virginia regiment first, and was then possibly conscripted later into the 29th. Again, joining the 29th was later in the war, not at the begininnig. One that joined the 5th Tennessee Mounted Infantry, U.S. joined up later as well. I don't believe he was conscripted, but volunteered. I blelieve the family had a strong Union sentiment as did the last one who joined the 8th Tennessee Inantry, U.S. I believe he, too, volunteered as did four of his brothers who fought in the same regiment.

    Not much help here, but if you know about East Tennesse and the war then you know the complexities behind every thought regarding why these men joined. My kith and kin really didn't have a dog in the fight. None of them owned slaves, not even the ones in Middle Tennessee, but that was common for most Tennesseans as a whole. East Tennessee is still a very strong Republican enclave.
    Joe Mode

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Why did they fight?

      Ken that was an outstanding memoir thank you so much for posting it.

      Sean M. Lamb
      The Bully Boys
      Sean M. Lamb

      [I]"Our Reg't is composed of Germans, Dutch-Americans, and Irish they being the majority and very hard set. Our company is composed of the same stock, we can not agree very well with the Irish."[/I]
      James A. Peifer
      Co. C 46th Penna. Vol. Inf.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Why did they fight?

        a good read for this topic is James Mcpherson's "What They Fought For: 1861-1865".

        I picked up this small book at my university library. One amazing quote from Thomas Rowland a Texan Volunteer is this:

        "Liberty and Freedom in this western world...so we dissolved our alliance with this oppressive foe, and are now enlisted in the holy cause of liberty and independence again"
        [FONT="Arial Black"]-Chris Conboy
        [/FONT]

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Why did they fight?

          One of my great grandfathers wrote the following:

          “Thursday 30th January 1862
          After mature consideration and consulting my wishes more perhaps than my judgment and friends, I determined to return with Peter, and try my fortunes in a new and unknown field - where honor and patriotism called me though health and friends forbid.”

          He was a captain with Morgan’s raiders C.S.A.

          My other great grandfather simply said to my grandfather that he went to Augusta and joined to serve his country.

          He was a private in Company H 37th Georgia Infantry, Bate’s Brigade C.S.A.


          Cordially,
          Sam Patterson

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Why did they fight?

            My Southern Ancestors fought because they believed they were illegaly invaded, one of my Southern Unionist ancestors didn't believe in secession, the others were fighting for the Union, but they were Alabama Mountain folk and didn't want to fight so the slave owner could keep his slaves,,.

            There was a split in the mountain people and the flatlanders,,,of the South.
            [B]Steve Whitlock
            Co. Cee 22nd Ark Inf
            1st Arkansas Bn
            Trans-Mississippi Brigade[/B]

            [COLOR="DarkRed"]"Man must die sometime and since he must die he can find no nobler death than that which overtakes him while fighting for his home, his fires, and his country.” Chilly McIntosh, Second Creek Regiment, Mtd. Vols[/COLOR]

            Comment

            Working...
            X