Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

A Masonic Incident

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • A Masonic Incident

    I found this story while browsing and thought some others might enjoy it.


    " The Civil War in Song and Story" Collected and Arranged by Frank Moore
    New York, 1882: PETER FENELON COLLIER, PUBLISHER
    page 299.


    A Masonic Incident - "The day after the battle of Antietam, the Fifth New Hampshire formed the picket line along the edge of the cornfield where Richardson's division fought. The reserve was in one edge of the corn, and the pickets about middle way of the field concealed in the corn, as the sharpshooters of the enemy fired on all who undertook to walk around on the battle-field at that locality. Early in the morning one of the wounded rebels, who lay just outside the pickets, called one of the New Hampshire men, and handed him a little slip of paper, on which he had, evidently with great difficulty succeeded in making some mystic signs in a circle with a bit of stick wet in blood. The soldier was begged to give it to some Freemason as soon as possible, and he took it to Colonel E.E. Cross, of his regiment. The Colonel was a Master Mason, but could not read the mystic token, it belonging to a higher degree. He therefore sent for Captain J.B. Perry, of the Fifth, who was a member of the thirty-second degree of Freemasonry, and showed him the letter. Captain Perry at once said there was a brother Mason in great peril, and must be rescued. Colonel Cross instantly sent for several brother Masons in the regiment, told the story, and in a few moments four "brothers of the mystic tie" were crawling stealthily through the corn to find the brother in distress. He was found, placed on a blanket, and at great risk drawn out of range of rebel rifles, and then carried to the Fifth New Hampshire hospital. He proved to be First Lieutenant Edon of the Alabama volunteers, badly wounded in the thigh and brest. A few hours and he would have perished. Lieutenant Edon informed his brothren of another wounded Mason, who, when brought out, proved to be a Lieutenant Colonel of a Georgia regiment. These two wounded rebel officers received the same attention as the wounded officers of the Fifth, and a warm friendship was established between men who a few hours before were in mortal combat. This is one of the thousand instances in which the Masonic bond has proved a blessing to mankind."


    S.R.B. Waveland Lodge #300
    Last edited by boozie; 01-05-2007, 10:49 AM. Reason: correction
    sigpic
    Grandad Wm. David Lee
    52nd Tenn. Reg't Co. B


    "If You Ain't Right, Get Right!"
    - Uncle Dave Macon

    www.40thindiana.wordpress.com/

  • #2
    Re: A Masonic Incident

    Thanks for posting that. One of the nicer monuments (at least to me) at Gettysburg, is the "Friend to Friend" monument which memorializes the fraternal bonds that transcended the war in many instances.

    Found this link with many stories about Freemasons during the war on the net.



    John Feagin
    Good Samaritan Lodge #336
    Gettysburg, PA
    John Feagin
    Member of the "currently out of the hobby but somehow can't keep away from it" mess
    Carroll Valley, PA
    Good Samaritan Lodge #336 F.&A.M. Gettysburg, PA

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: A Masonic Incident

      Maybe I'm wrong, but this would seem to support the long-held sentiment that Freemasons will regard membership in that organization, and the duties owed to other members, as superceding the duties one owes one's country, and that this example serves as proof positive. Could that actually be said to be true, generally speaking? It's kind of a scary proposition, really. I wonder if other Federal troops suffered as a result of this perilous rescue operation afforded to a man who, at that particular time, was an enemy of the state.

      Respectfully,
      Joe Marti

      ...and yes, I did use the search function...

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: A Masonic Incident

        Lost during the Great Crash of '06:

        "Charles A. Near, of whom we have already written, was a soldier in the Civil War. He enlisted from Canastota in Company G, One Hundred and Fifty-seventh New York Volunteer Infantry, going into the service a private, and returning at the close of the war with the rank of Captain. At Honey Hill he was wounded by a ball that ploughed its way across his temple. It was a close call for his life; but he had the wound dressed, and immediately returned to the field. He was recklessly brave, as was evinced on the Gettysburg battlefield, when his Captain, Harrison Frank, was shot down. Although the Confederates were right upon him, he stayed by his Captain until he breathed his last. He was captured by the enemy, and all his valuables taken from him. When they tried to take a Masonic ring from his finger which Captain Frank had given him, he told them they would get it when he was dead, and not before; and some of them, recognizing the Masonic emblem, let him go."

        [FONT=Times New Roman]Yours most respectfully, your obedient servant,[/FONT]
        [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
        [FONT=Times New Roman]R. L. ("Rob") Griffiths.[/FONT]
        [FONT=Times New Roman][I]Member, Civil War Preservation Trust.[/I][/FONT]
        [FONT=Times New Roman][I]Authentic Campaigner member since November 10th, 2004.[/I][/FONT]

        [FONT=Times New Roman][I]"I am not aware of ever having used a profane expletive in my life, but I would have the charity to excuse those who may have done so, if they were in charge of a train of Mexican pack mules at the time."[/I] - U. S. Grant[I].[/I][/FONT]

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: A Masonic Incident

          Mr. Marti,

          "Colonel Cross instantly sent for several brother Masons in the regiment, told the story, and in a few moments four "brothers of the mystic tie" were crawling stealthily through the corn to find the brother in distress. He was found, placed on a blanket, and at great risk drawn out of range of rebel rifles, and then carried to the Fifth New Hampshire hospital"

          It appears that the only ones risking anything were fellow Brothers. I for one would do the same for mine and they for me (at least I hope). Personally speaking, I wouldn't put anyone else at risk that is not a Brother, because simply it's not your obligation, it's mine/ours.

          Patrick Landrum
          Orange Grove Lodge #635
          Patrick Landrum
          Independent Rifles

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: A Masonic Incident

            Originally posted by mtvernon View Post
            Maybe I'm wrong, but this would seem to support the long-held sentiment that Freemasons will regard membership in that organization, and the duties owed to other members, as superceding the duties one owes one's country, and that this example serves as proof positive. Could that actually be said to be true, generally speaking? It's kind of a scary proposition, really. I wonder if other Federal troops suffered as a result of this perilous rescue operation afforded to a man who, at that particular time, was an enemy of the state.

            Respectfully,
            If you are wondering if you are wrong, then you really don't understand your question.../G\

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: A Masonic Incident

              Originally posted by mtvernon View Post
              Maybe I'm wrong, but this would seem to support the long-held sentiment that Freemasons will regard membership in that organization, and the duties owed to other members, as superceding the duties one owes one's country, and that this example serves as proof positive. Could that actually be said to be true, generally speaking? It's kind of a scary proposition, really. I wonder if other Federal troops suffered as a result of this perilous rescue operation afforded to a man who, at that particular time, was an enemy of the state.

              Respectfully,
              Rendering medical aid to a wounded enemy is not a traitorous act. As a matter of fact, the Military is required to provide the same quality of medical care to our foes, as we do our comrades. This is not only morally correct, it is actually written in modern regulations.

              There are numerous examples of Masons coming to the aid of fellow Masons during armed conflicts. I have several referances which provide examples going back as far as the French and Indain War although through to WWII.

              The duties owed to fellow Masons does not supercede the obligations one owes to their Govt. and Civil authorities. This fact is clearly written in all of the By-Laws of every Grand Lodge that I am familiar with.
              Brian Hicks
              Widows' Sons Mess

              Known lately to associate with the WIG and the Armory Guards

              "He's a good enough fellow... but I fear he may be another Alcibiades."

              “Every man ever got a statue made of him was one kinda sumbitch or another. It ain’t about you. It’s about what THEY need.”CAPTAIN MALCOLM REYNOLDS

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: A Masonic Incident

                "Originally Posted by mtvernon
                Maybe I'm wrong, but this would seem to support the long-held sentiment that Freemasons will regard membership in that organization, and the duties owed to other members, as superceding the duties one owes one's country, and that this example serves as proof positive. Could that actually be said to be true, generally speaking? It's kind of a scary proposition, really. I wonder if other Federal troops suffered as a result of this perilous rescue operation afforded to a man who, at that particular time, was an enemy of the state"

                We are taught as Masons that we have an obligation to God, our country AND to our fellow man. The fact that Freemasonry can transcend the battle lines during war I think speaks favorable for the fraternity and so I respectively disagree with the gentleman's opinion.

                Brother Hicks, there are written records (debates) of the Grand Lodges at the time we are speaking of discussing our duties as Masons, specifically one's duty to country. I have a copy of one from one of the southern Grand Lodges at home that I will post later to illustrate the agonizing decisions our Civil War fraternal brothers had to deal with.

                Rich Schultz,
                Past Master of Clifton Lodge #203 (NJ)
                Last edited by PvtSchultz; 01-05-2007, 08:26 AM.
                Pvt Rich Schultz
                6th NHV, Co. C
                Clifton Lodge #203 F&AM

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: A Masonic Incident

                  Well said Brother Hicks.
                  Brian Wilson / Killen lodge 788

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: A Masonic Incident

                    I agree whole heartedly. There are some great Masons in our history. Gen Hancock, Gen Armistad, George Washington, Ben Franklin, and Gerald Ford to name a few
                    God, Country, and fellow Brothers,
                    Dave Prince
                    Walled Lake Lodge #529
                    Dave Prince

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: A Masonic Incident

                      Originally posted by coastaltrash View Post
                      It appears that the only ones risking anything were fellow Brothers. I for one would do the same for mine and they for me (at least I hope). Personally speaking, I wouldn't put anyone else at risk that is not a Brother, because simply it's not your obligation, it's mine/ours.
                      Mr. Landrum,

                      If I understand you correctly, your reply confirms my suspicion that the ties to Masonry do supercede the duties to one's country. My long-held assumption has been that one's obligation to one's country is a greater obligation (especially for a soldier in a time of war) than to a fraternal society. Perhaps I misunderstand you?

                      Respectfully,
                      Joe Marti

                      ...and yes, I did use the search function...

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: A Masonic Incident

                        Originally posted by Dale Beasley View Post
                        If you are wondering if you are wrong, then you really don't understand your question.../G\
                        Perhaps you can enlighten me, and I can then ask the proper question.

                        Respectfully,
                        Joe Marti

                        ...and yes, I did use the search function...

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: A Masonic Incident

                          Originally posted by mtvernon View Post
                          Perhaps you can enlighten me, and I can then ask the proper question.

                          Respectfully,
                          I am unable to enlighten you. You must do that on your own. Giving medical aid to an enemy soldier is not an act of treason, otherwise I would have been up for charges in Iraq. Brother Hicks explained it well enough, please refer to his post. Good luck in your search for knowledge.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: A Masonic Incident

                            Originally posted by BrianHicks View Post
                            Rendering medical aid to a wounded enemy is not a traitorous act. As a matter of fact, the Military is required to provide the same quality of medical care to our foes, as we do our comrades. This is not only morally correct, it is actually written in modern regulations...[T]he duties owed to fellow Masons does not supersede the obligations one owes to their Govt. and Civil authorities. This fact is clearly written in all of the By-Laws of every Grand Lodge that I am familiar with.
                            Mr. Hicks, et al.,

                            I seem to have raised some hackles on this subject, and I want to apologize for my clumsiness if I offended anyone. Not being a Mason I am not well-versed in it's practices, but I was merely looking at this historical incident and trying to come to an understanding of what duty means to those who are Masons.

                            Again, with all due respect, and acknowledging the demand to care for the enemy wounded, this act still seems to have gone far above the call of duty to the level of heroism simply due to the fact that the wounded enemy was a fellow Mason. Now, maybe all is well and good. That's fine. But did those four Masons from the Federal side go to the same lengths to rescue and care for all the wounded enemies? It doesn't say in the text but I would assume the answer is no. So it would seem that membership in this particular organization places a proportionally higher importance on the lives of fellow members and really transcends the mere duty to care for enemy wounded.

                            Is this correct? It would seem so from the responses I've seen so far. Was this rescue operation right or wrong? Yes or no, but determining that was not my goal; I primarily was interested in identifying the hierarchy of loyalty owed by a member of the Masons. I am not trying to call anyone a traitor, necessarily. But if my suspicion is correct then I find it disconcerting.

                            If you'll allow a hypothetical example, maybe it will illustrate my discomfort. Please, do not take this the wrong way - it is fictional and I'm not trying to paint anyone with a treasonous brush. But let's say an Iraqi insurgent who happens to be a Mason (I know, I know, but go with it) is wounded and communicates to US forces in a similar way as in our example. Do four US soldiers, Masons themselves, crawl through enemy fire to rescue this man? And if they do, are their fellow troops congratulatory? Or do they look at them and wonder why they risked their lives for an enemy who had intended to kill them? I know there are problems with my example but still the crux of it remains: where does duty reign supreme in these men?

                            Again, I know some people reading this will be upset, and I want to reiterate that causing discomfort is not my goal. I don't think flippant remarks advance the discussion and I'm hoping that those who do wish to comment adhere to the norms of debate and remember that we are discussing an issue, not a person. As such, attacks on a person are not only destructive to discourse, but show a lack of maturity and openness on part of the person who makes such remarks. I now realize this is a sensitive topic, and I wish to remain sensitive to those who disagree, but I do think it's a topic worthy of discussion.

                            Respectfully,
                            Last edited by mtvernon; 01-05-2007, 10:59 PM.
                            Joe Marti

                            ...and yes, I did use the search function...

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: A Masonic Incident

                              Originally posted by Beaner View Post
                              I agree whole heartedly. There are some great Masons in our history. Gen Hancock, Gen Armistad, George Washington, Ben Franklin, and Gerald Ford to name a few
                              God, Country, and fellow Brothers,
                              Dave Prince
                              Walled Lake Lodge #529
                              Yeah...None of us will jump ship anytime soon.We all have duties and so did they.The Brotherhood is bigger than any one man we are taught that from the start.Good threads!
                              Kiev Thomason
                              a.k.a. King Corn:baring_te
                              WIG
                              Armory Guards
                              Forest Park Lodge #399
                              Forest Park GA.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X