Re: Songs for Children
Again, a few of these were not considered children's tunes at the time, as they were still popular adult entertainment, keeping in mind they were performed in blackface dialect. In particular O Susanna and Buffalo Gals, and perhaps Arkansas Traveller. Some here earlier suggested Minstrel songs were not appropriate for families and children of repectable upbringing at the time, though, as I mentioned before, I think by the 1860s the Minstrel performances had been cleaned up.
I thought of another song for children - "Listen to The Mockingbird" - a Lincoln favorite.
The thing left to decide in this matter -- Is it correct to actually reenact Minstrel songs in period children's choir or school venue? And, how can we authentically do that unless we have the kids attempt to sing in dialect (which is too awkward today), as they would have heard it? This is the AC so I ask.
I feel it's ok to sing Minstrel songs of the time to children, because they probably did hear them, but to suppose and reenact that the children sang them in a choir or school setting, no -- not until much later in the century when they became children's classics.
Dan Wykes
Originally posted by pambryda
View Post
I thought of another song for children - "Listen to The Mockingbird" - a Lincoln favorite.
The thing left to decide in this matter -- Is it correct to actually reenact Minstrel songs in period children's choir or school venue? And, how can we authentically do that unless we have the kids attempt to sing in dialect (which is too awkward today), as they would have heard it? This is the AC so I ask.
I feel it's ok to sing Minstrel songs of the time to children, because they probably did hear them, but to suppose and reenact that the children sang them in a choir or school setting, no -- not until much later in the century when they became children's classics.
Dan Wykes
Comment