Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

    Gents-

    At the risk of being lynched. I have to ask. I checked the AC search engine and all that is refrenced in regards to grommets for a gum blanket is the "correct small grommets".

    What is the exact correct size?


    Which brings me to my next question. Who has correct gum blankets in stock?
    Louis Zenti

    Pvt. Albert R. Cumpston (Company B, 12th Illinois Vol. Inf.-W.I.A. February 15, 1862)
    Pvt. William H. Cumpston (Company B, 12th Illinois Vol. Inf.-K.I.A. February 15, 1862 Ft. Donelson)
    Pvt. Simon Sams (Co. C, 18th Iowa Inf.-K.I.A. January 8, 1863 Springfield, MO)
    Pvt. Elisha Cox (Co. C, 26th North Carolina Inf.-W.I.A. July 3, 1863 Gettysburg)

    "...in the hottest of the fight, some of the rebs yelled out...them must be Iowa boys". Charles O. Musser 29th Iowa Infantry

  • #2
    Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

    Someone please correct me if I am mistaken, but...

    I believe the correct size grommet for Fed gums/ponchos is a size "0", which has a 1/4" hole.
    John Wickett
    Former Carpetbagger
    Administrator (We got rules here! Be Nice - Sign Your Name - No Farbisms)

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

      Click image for larger version

Name:	gumblanket grommets.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	106.9 KB
ID:	223515

      I had to dig back in the memory for this info. Here are three dug grommets lying on a (Jarnagin ??) rubber blanket. About 20 years ago the grommets sutlers were using were much larger. This was brought to Jarnagins attention and he was one of the first to use smaller grommets. The original grommets are approximately 1.5 cm in OD. All three originals are slightly different and probably made by different contractors. The hole size on the Jarnagin grommet looks slightly larger than two of the originals but the OD is exactly the same as one of the originals. Today there are other people making rubber blankets with correct size grommets. I just happened to have an old Jarnagin I obtained after he changed the grommet size.
      Jim Mayo
      Portsmouth Rifles, Company G, 9th Va. Inf.

      CW Show and Tell Site
      http://www.angelfire.com/ma4/j_mayo/index.html

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

        Thanks for the replies John and Jim.

        So a correct sized grommet should be roughly 9/16" (overall/outside dimension) with about a 1/4" hole?

        And a correct gumblanket should have 6 grommets?

        The only vendor I have been able to find that has gum blankets in stock is a mainstream outfit and when asked said their grommets were the size of a quarter-which would be almost 2.5 cm or 15/16".

        Anybody wanting to part with one or know of a vendor with stock??
        Louis Zenti

        Pvt. Albert R. Cumpston (Company B, 12th Illinois Vol. Inf.-W.I.A. February 15, 1862)
        Pvt. William H. Cumpston (Company B, 12th Illinois Vol. Inf.-K.I.A. February 15, 1862 Ft. Donelson)
        Pvt. Simon Sams (Co. C, 18th Iowa Inf.-K.I.A. January 8, 1863 Springfield, MO)
        Pvt. Elisha Cox (Co. C, 26th North Carolina Inf.-W.I.A. July 3, 1863 Gettysburg)

        "...in the hottest of the fight, some of the rebs yelled out...them must be Iowa boys". Charles O. Musser 29th Iowa Infantry

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

          Lederarsenal makes a dandy gum! Though they're in Germany, they generally ship pretty fast.
          John Wickett
          Former Carpetbagger
          Administrator (We got rules here! Be Nice - Sign Your Name - No Farbisms)

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

            What's a correct sized grommet? I've seen 3 original gum blankets and all three had different sized grommets (GNMP). largest (outside diameter) was 9/16ths smallest 5/16ths. BTW, all three holes were different sizes too and I'd swear in a court of law one of the three had copper grommets, but I wasn't allowed to scratch them to find out.

            What's a correct grommet? Whatever the contractor had on hand when he filled his order way back in 186x.
            [FONT="Book Antiqua"]"Grumpy" Dave Towsen
            Past President Potomac Legion
            Long time member Columbia Rifles
            Who will care for Mother now?[/FONT]

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

              Thanks for keeping us honest, Dave!
              John Wickett
              Former Carpetbagger
              Administrator (We got rules here! Be Nice - Sign Your Name - No Farbisms)

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

                Thanks for the information...everyone!

                And thanks for the heads-up on where to go for gum blanket John.

                I was very close to buying a gum blanket from a mainstream vendor but figured I would confirm the grommet question here first before buying and I am glad I did.

                A small difference sure but lets face it...it's all in the details.

                Thanks!
                Last edited by Cumpston1862; 10-10-2012, 03:02 PM.
                Louis Zenti

                Pvt. Albert R. Cumpston (Company B, 12th Illinois Vol. Inf.-W.I.A. February 15, 1862)
                Pvt. William H. Cumpston (Company B, 12th Illinois Vol. Inf.-K.I.A. February 15, 1862 Ft. Donelson)
                Pvt. Simon Sams (Co. C, 18th Iowa Inf.-K.I.A. January 8, 1863 Springfield, MO)
                Pvt. Elisha Cox (Co. C, 26th North Carolina Inf.-W.I.A. July 3, 1863 Gettysburg)

                "...in the hottest of the fight, some of the rebs yelled out...them must be Iowa boys". Charles O. Musser 29th Iowa Infantry

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

                  None of the three were the same size neither.

                  There's what the book says and then there's what actually happened. It's fun to learn the reality of the 1860's.
                  [FONT="Book Antiqua"]"Grumpy" Dave Towsen
                  Past President Potomac Legion
                  Long time member Columbia Rifles
                  Who will care for Mother now?[/FONT]

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

                    Here are two grommets I've dug recently out of a Union camp near Grand Junction TN

                    Mike McGee
                    Cure All Mess ~ Hard Case Boys
                    Co A, 4th Tennessee Infantry Regiment "The Shelby Greys"
                    Co C, 25th Regiment, Indiana Infantry


                    Pvt. Francis "Frank" Agee- G, G, G-Uncle
                    Co H, 22nd Tennessee Infantry Regiment
                    KIA Battle of Shiloh-April 6, 1862
                    Resting in Peace on that Hallowed Ground

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

                      Thanks for posting the pic with nice examples Mike!

                      Kind of eyeballing it but are both your examples about 3/4" overall with a 3/8" hole opening?
                      Louis Zenti

                      Pvt. Albert R. Cumpston (Company B, 12th Illinois Vol. Inf.-W.I.A. February 15, 1862)
                      Pvt. William H. Cumpston (Company B, 12th Illinois Vol. Inf.-K.I.A. February 15, 1862 Ft. Donelson)
                      Pvt. Simon Sams (Co. C, 18th Iowa Inf.-K.I.A. January 8, 1863 Springfield, MO)
                      Pvt. Elisha Cox (Co. C, 26th North Carolina Inf.-W.I.A. July 3, 1863 Gettysburg)

                      "...in the hottest of the fight, some of the rebs yelled out...them must be Iowa boys". Charles O. Musser 29th Iowa Infantry

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

                        Hallo!

                        I have mispaced my "U.S.S. Maple Leaf" article.

                        Can anyone post the data on the recovered originals to expand the discussion here?

                        Curt
                        Curt Schmidt
                        In gleichem Schritt und Tritt, Curt Schmidt

                        -Hard and sharp as flint...secret, and self-contained, and solitary as an oyster.
                        -Haplogroup R1b M343 (Subclade R1b1a2 M269)
                        -Pointless Folksy Wisdom Mess, Oblio Lodge #1
                        -Vastly Ignorant
                        -Often incorrect, technically, historically, factually.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

                          I'd say that's about as close as you're going to get.



                          Mike McGee
                          Cure All Mess ~ Hard Case Boys
                          Co A, 4th Tennessee Infantry Regiment "The Shelby Greys"
                          Co C, 25th Regiment, Indiana Infantry


                          Pvt. Francis "Frank" Agee- G, G, G-Uncle
                          Co H, 22nd Tennessee Infantry Regiment
                          KIA Battle of Shiloh-April 6, 1862
                          Resting in Peace on that Hallowed Ground

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

                            Here's a swag at interpretting the dimensions:
                            Click image for larger version

Name:	GrommetScale.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	20.4 KB
ID:	223518

                            Does that look right?
                            John Wickett
                            Former Carpetbagger
                            Administrator (We got rules here! Be Nice - Sign Your Name - No Farbisms)

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Actual Measurement On A Correct Size Grommet

                              Great pics guys!

                              I would agree with Dave there would and does seem to be some variance by the different contractors using what they had on hand when they fulfilled their orders. But for the most part I think a proper repro gum blanket should have a grommet that has an overall outside dimension of 12 to 13/16" and the opening/hole would seem to be a 5/16th to 3/8" based on the examples we have seen in this discussion.

                              Keeping in mind there will be something to throw this all off at some point lurking in a collection or museum somewhere :)
                              Louis Zenti

                              Pvt. Albert R. Cumpston (Company B, 12th Illinois Vol. Inf.-W.I.A. February 15, 1862)
                              Pvt. William H. Cumpston (Company B, 12th Illinois Vol. Inf.-K.I.A. February 15, 1862 Ft. Donelson)
                              Pvt. Simon Sams (Co. C, 18th Iowa Inf.-K.I.A. January 8, 1863 Springfield, MO)
                              Pvt. Elisha Cox (Co. C, 26th North Carolina Inf.-W.I.A. July 3, 1863 Gettysburg)

                              "...in the hottest of the fight, some of the rebs yelled out...them must be Iowa boys". Charles O. Musser 29th Iowa Infantry

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X