Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

    Well, the long awaited mounted adjunct to the 150th Shiloh has come and gone and I must say that it was all that we had hoped it would be! How great was it for horsemen to come together from all over the country for a common goal and effort. Literally, we had cavalrymen who came from Alaska to Florida and all points in between and folks, ...... that spans a whole bunch of miles. All had a drive and desire to put forth their best impression and pay homage to those cavalrymen who have gone before.

    On Wednesday, we arrived at Corinth, Mississippi to report in and then begin the task of moving our trucks/trailers to a secured parking area that our Col. Ronnie Fullwood had worked out which gave us a great location from which to leave when all was over. We were shuttled back to Corinth and eventually things settled down and we curled up under a blanket and slept under the stars.

    Early Thursday morning we got up, had breakfast and formed up. After some appropriate remarks for the occasion, we cast off in a northeasterly direction following the path that Generals Hardee and Polk took 150 years earlier. Our first day covered about 13 miles. It was hotter than expected and some of the infantry fellas really suffered on those roads and a few went down. Thank goodness we had someone coming behind to help take care of them. Thursday night we were actually able to set up camp on the very ground that the original soldiers camped on. The owner of the property came out and gave us family history reports of when his great grandmother, as a small girl, saw the soldiers pass by their home.

    The next morning we rose at 5:00 a.m., tacked up in the dark, formed up and left out. Just as we were leaving out, it began to rain and continued to do so until about noon. We arrived at the actual ground where Forrest engaged Sherman in the closing portions of Shiloh at what was called “Fallen Timbers.” The rain was coming down pretty good at this point but just to be working on that very ground was a moving experience. Afterwards, we rode to our wagons and re-supplied as well as changed out to portray the 11th Illinois Cav. We formed up and rode another 5 miles across the park and down Beauregard Rd., past Shiloh Church, Ruggles battery site, the Hornet's nest, the sunken road, etc, etc, until we arrived at the high ground next to Pittsburg landing. There we set up camp for the night and during the night, the men of the 15th Iowa arrived from the paddleboats and set up their camp. Early the next morning, we headed over to watch the last of the boats arrive, only to find out that the transfer took place earlier than expected and all of the men arrived while it was still dark. After conferring with Col. Woodburn, we posted our cavalry column at the top of the hill to receive the 400 plus men of the 15th Iowa. Now, I have seen some impressive groups form and move throughout the years, but to see the men of this unit march out with drum and fife playing a stirring tune and with their officers properly mounted and accoutered and to be fortunate to be at the forefront of that column while providing a mounted escort, was such a site of martial excellence that the very thought of it now stands the hair up on the back of my neck!! What an experience!

    We moved out in the lead and traveled across the park, over roads and woods and eventually got to a point near the event site. There, the officers of the 15th Iowa said that they were going to stand down and do a weapons inspection and that we were relieved of our duties. We rode a little further and soon were ambushed by some CS cavalry and were greatly outnumbered. We formed and responded but rallied back to a safe point and proceeded on to change back to Forrest's Cavalry and concluded the remainder of the event.

    So many highpoints and so much hard work but I must point out the hard work and planning of our own Col. Ronnie Fullwood, who worked with the people in Corinth and Shiloh and all points in between to put together the route and so much that we were able to enjoy and secondly I must commend and thank our own Ken Knopp for so much hard work behind the scenes to help with support, inspections, guidelines, and doing all of the stuff that usually doesn't get seen but is so very important for success. Also, regarding Ken, I was so happy to see that he was able to mount up and make the ride with us from the wagons to Pittsburg Landing! Some may not know that while a tremendous horseman in earlier years, injuries have prevented Ken from being able to practice and involve himself in his first love of riding. But due to hard work and exercise, he has worked out to the point that he was able to complete this ride. It meant more to me to see him back in the saddle than maybe everything else combined! Congrats, Ken!

    So, in closing I want to thank each and every one of you who participated and came down to see this project through. I know so many of you made plans to make it and yet were not able to due to circumstances outside your control. I want to thank you also for making the efforts and plans.

    Until the next time......................

    Mark
    J. Mark Choate
    7th TN. Cavalry, Co. D.

    "Let history dictate our impressions.......not the other way around!"

  • #2
    Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

    Well, what can I say except that there will NEVER be another event like this! I had so much fun and I wish that I could sum everything up but I will just site a few.

    1. Riding with a group of men from all over the country, had a fellow from Montanna (Casey Mott) and a Texan (John Clinch) in just my set!
    2. The comradery between troopers! Casey, I will never be able to hear an Indian in a movie without busting a gut laughing, and I'm sure John will say the same!
    3. Camping on original ground Thursday night....Raised the hair on the back of my neck!
    4. Learning the value of a set, that was so cool to have a group that was relient on each other, rode as a set, camped as a set, saddled as a set, and ate as a set. My hats are off to John and Casey because that made the event for me.
    5. Experiencing boredom when waiting on the infantry to catch up
    There were a VERY few cons but I'll list them.
    1. Pistols, there were a few fellas that decided that they just couldn't live without multiple pistols, I saw one trooper present himself for inspection with one and upon passing went to his trailer and snuck two more into camp. Had another guy justify his 3 revolvers as being under the Partisan Law of South Carolina while we were portraying Forrest's Cavalry! C'mon guys Ken's Guidelines called for one or none!
    2. Troopers wanting to argue with the NCO's about tactics, there might be a different way to do things, but when you fall in with another unit you'd better keep your mouth shut, keep the formation and follow orders!

    The pros far out wayed the cons in my opinion, and I will probabley be in this hobby the rest of my life and still not find an event like this one!
    Andrew Verdon

    7th Tennessee Cavalry Company D

    Tennessee Plowboy #1 of the "Far Flung Mess"

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

      I tried very hard to be true to the period. No bling, no forage cap and one pistol. The number of women in the units bothered me more than anything not to mention the walkie talkies. But overall a positive experience. The battle on Saturday morning filled me with emotion as I looked through the fog of gunpowder to see the sun as an orange orb rising above the tree line. Brought tears to my eyes.
      Dennis DeAtley
      North Texas


      I think I understand what military fame is; to be killed on the field of battle and have your name misspelled in the newspapers.
      [B]William Tecumseh Sherman [/B]

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

        Originally posted by Forrestcavalryman View Post
        The pros far out wayed the cons in my opinion, and I will probabley be in this hobby the rest of my life and still not find an event like this one!
        Sounds like you guys had a high time, and I am very glad to hear that it worked out so well!

        I have to say that I very much hope you are wrong about not finding another event like this one. It is very much in our power to make events like this happen. We've just got to put in the effort, and creativity to make it work.

        Take care,
        Tom Craig
        1st Maine Cavalry
        Tom Craig

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

          Tom,

          I tend to agree. What gives me hope is the size of the crowds that showed up on Saturday and Sunday to see this event. There still is a lot of interest in the CW. As I drove back to Texas on Sunday night, at every gas stop from Corinth, MS to Texarkana people asked if I was at Shiloh. Most had been there as specators and were excited about it.
          Dennis DeAtley
          North Texas


          I think I understand what military fame is; to be killed on the field of battle and have your name misspelled in the newspapers.
          [B]William Tecumseh Sherman [/B]

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

            [QUOTE=Forrestcavalryman;221152
            1. Pistols, there were a few fellas that decided that they just couldn't live without multiple pistols, I saw one trooper present himself for inspection with one and upon passing went to his trailer and snuck two more into camp. Had another guy justify his 3 revolvers as being under the Partisan Law of South Carolina while we were portraying Forrest's Cavalry! C'mon guys Ken's Guidelines called for one or none!
            [/QUOTE]

            So, not having been there, but as an observer of this thread, this begs the question: Did anyone "call out" this person? Did any of the NCOs or officers tell him to ditch the additional pistols?

            This has been a burr under my saddle for a long time - it's one thing to have Guidelines, but it takes cohones to enforce them. A decade or so ago, when I rode with the Critters, there was no problem in anyone in the group calling someone or something out that wasn't correct. Just ask any of the original Critters - Guy Musgrove, Pete Petersen, Tommy Jackson. Paddy McAllister - that are still in the hobby. That being said, there are ways to do it and ways that just pi** people off. The former is preferred and offers a "teaching moment." Maybe additional inspections during the event by NCOs before leaving camp each morning, or ensuring that no one is riding back to the trailer after having passed initial inspection.

            As Andrew states, guys that don't follow the guidelines spoil it for the ones that work hard to do it correctly.
            Mike Ventura
            Shannon's Scouts

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

              Mike, I believe the trooper in question was called out as I did not see them later. But as you stated it does annoy the ones who try to do it right, his argument was that he would need them for Fallen Timbers to which I told him that I was only using a shotgun. I honestly have to say that I did enjoy only having to worry about the longarm during Fallen Timbers, because a buddy of mine dropped his powder flask while trying to reload his revolver on horseback and someone walked off with it!
              Andrew Verdon

              7th Tennessee Cavalry Company D

              Tennessee Plowboy #1 of the "Far Flung Mess"

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

                The extra revolver was stowed away prior to cast off.

                regards,
                Mark
                J. Mark Choate
                7th TN. Cavalry, Co. D.

                "Let history dictate our impressions.......not the other way around!"

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

                  Mark - GREAT. Thought you'd be on top of it!
                  Mike Ventura
                  Shannon's Scouts

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

                    Great event on so many levels! The Paddle wheel boat experiences were cool. I was blessed to see one come in and even though it was dark, the stillness of the night on the water, the cockswains whisltles, muffled commands, hearing the tramp of the men and then seeing them making their way up the hill in the dark was surreal. Seeing them again the next day in formation marching 500 hundred strong escorted by properly mounted officers (on Grimsley saddles with schabraques and brass dragon bits ) was a super fantastic thrill. Matt Woodburn's vison, organization and leadership skills are a tremendous asset to this hobby! My hats off to the Iowa infantry too. Their march from the landing to the battelefield then into battle for three hours was grueling and impressed me with their pluck. Moreoever, their attention to military decorum, details, their stellar impressions and their dedication to that effort is something we in the cavalry can learn from.
                    The main stream battle was....well, what they are, but, "our" pre-event march from Corinth, and the march from the paddle wheel boats at Pittsburg Landing was unsurpassed in its multiple authentic experiences.
                    As for the Forrest's Cavalry march.....My thanks to all that worked so hard to make this a good cav event especially Ronnie Fullwood who gave up so much in precious time, resources (pulling the locals together to assist us) and as usual, sharing his vast knowledge about this battlefield; MArk Choate for his usual "well oiled" behind the scenes organization and leadership; Jeff Tull for the support effort with the "pursuit" vehicles and last but certainly not least, Keith Willingham for "literally" putting it all together and following it through to execution. Keith deserves special recognition! Thanks Keith!!
                    I know the cavalry had two horses go down with lamness on the march but at least sore backs and other injuries to man and beast were minimal. Thank you guys for taking the guidelines serious and getting you and yours in shape for the ride....so important. On that note of authenticity- most of the guys looked good, more than a few outstanding and a couple "not so good". It was great to have so many make changes (even at the last minute) to conform such as "loosing" the breast straps, an un-authentic bit, cinch or two, etc. I should point out that "hats" are still an issue. It is the one area that needs work but is easily improved. Why we insist on having so many "cowboy" or 1880's types is beyond me. Another pet peeve was hardware.....not enough proper horseshoe and roller bridle buckles, iron saddle hardware etc. even on some of the best kits. Overall, weapons were fine....as noted. Clothing could be done better but 85% were excellent to "OK". In short, the impressions have improved alot and are getting better every year. Keep improving guys!
                    Sgt Scott Lyndon told me the infantry experienced 38% casualties on the march. I gotta say, my hats off to them! Making that kind of march in that heat on pavement had to be grueling. I was impressed with some of their efforts. The oxen were a great sight and the fact these men and animals made every bit of the march on foot is another testimony.
                    We often commented on this while on the march and here too on the AC but I ask all to seriously think about our forebearers who would routinely make 20 to 35 mile marches, day after day and often in to the night and then sometimes, go right into battle and then turn around and march back again. Tough work! Never easy. Sure, they and their hroses were in better condition for this but for us today its these kind of experiences that command our respect and increase our understanding of these men when we read about them. Really give us a new perspective- huh?
                    For me personally, getting back into the saddle again was a feeling of satisfaction that I cannot properly describe. I have been working towards this for a long time and while I wont be riding much in the future and certainly not hard, you will see me mounted more at some events. Sure got my juices going!! Thank you Ronnie Tucker and MArk Choate!

                    Ken R Knopp
                    Last edited by Ken Knopp; 04-03-2012, 11:19 PM.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

                      Hindsight is a wonderful thing. If I could have done things different, I would have attended the Adjutant event vice the "other" event, but I was their to support a friend with his sutlerly. After this many years the "battles" have lost their luster and now I know why I had stopped attending reenactments. The only bright spots to the event were: seeing old friends, meeting and sitting down and talking to Ken at Doug's tent, camping on the Fallen Timbers battlefield on Thursday night, riding my trusty mount for the last time (he is retiring).
                      After attending this event, I will probably start looking really hard at what events I will be attending.
                      Bill Jordan

                      “I ended the war a horse ahead.”
                      Nathan Bedford Forrest

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

                        I cannot begin to express my thanks to all members of the 7th Tennessee Cavalry, Company D for allowing an Alaskan to participate in your ride from Corinth. Before and during the ride to Shiloh, your generosity and advice was overwhelming. I learned a great many things on that ride: heat can melt an Alaskan, sabers can be more dangerous to the bearer than the enemy, age does not limit living a dream and there are still fine people on the planet. My many thanks again. My home in Alaska is always open to the 7th.

                        Richard Wages
                        Fairbanks. Alaska

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

                          Richard,

                          It was a pleasure to meet you and your son and buddy. Y'all did an excellent job and had a great attitude! We were very happy to have you in the ranks and hope you will come south again soon.

                          Bill,
                          As to the "hindsight".......I have made some of my best decisions in that mode. Sadly, the die was usually cast by the time I made them.

                          Seriously, with as relatively few as there are of us in this branch and slice of the hobby, we really do need to try to pool our efforts and "jine up" when possible. We had about a half a dozen or so kindred spirits that were there in some other capacity or another and it would have be great to all have been together. That being said, I certainly do understand commitments to friends and pards.

                          regards,
                          Mark
                          J. Mark Choate
                          7th TN. Cavalry, Co. D.

                          "Let history dictate our impressions.......not the other way around!"

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

                            I too must say that I felt at home with the 7th.
                            John Clinch ~ The Texas Waddi of the "Far Flung Mess"

                            "Fighting the Texans is like walking into a den of wildcats"- Union private
                            "When a Texan fancies he'll take his chances, chances will be taken..."

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: 150th Battle of Shiloh - Mounted Cavalry Adjunct! AFTER ACTION REPORT

                              John,
                              Was great to have you and "mule" on the event. According to Andrew Verdon, we are to adopt you and Casey into the ranks and we do so with eagerness!

                              Mark
                              Last edited by Mark Choate; 04-06-2012, 09:24 AM.
                              J. Mark Choate
                              7th TN. Cavalry, Co. D.

                              "Let history dictate our impressions.......not the other way around!"

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X