Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The End of Malaise 2008

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The End of Malaise 2008

    Looking back at this year and forward into the next year, I have a declaration of sorts to make and yes this will be one of those op-ed pieces, that I am famous for, but it will be extremely optimistic. :D

    From mid 2005 to late 2007, this side of the hobby seemed to suffered some morale problems and malaise for conditions that were more an existential crisis. A malaise that wallowed in the mantra of "whats wrong with the hobby?" A malaise that did not reflect the true capabilities and commitment of the campaigner/progressive movement, that is alive and well, thank you very much.
    Everything from the economy, gas prices and the War on Terrorism was blamed for the "demise" and "downfall" of the hobby.

    The result of the malaise was not the fault of mainstream reenactors or burned out campaigners, but resided squarely with that peculiar animal called the "keyboard campaigner." 2008 was the resurrection of the hobby (that I wasn't sure was ever dead) or more accurately we aren't hearing from a lot of malcontent people who were controlling a false perception via electrons on forums.

    We can now declare that:

    1. A small living history or military event can be just as accurate and interesting (if not more) than a huge event involving large numbers.

    2 Accurate gear and equipment cannot compensate for a bad first person impression. The good gear gets them in to the party, the jerk underneath the jean wool ruins it for everyone.

    3. The people and not the props make it happen. Events provide the play space, but the quality people with good impressions, wise gear investments and cooperative attitudes are the heart of a good event.

    4. Preparation is the key to our success. It could be wearing the right gear, doing research, site preparation or improving your impression. If we prepare far in advance and use other similar events as our rehearsals, success will be certain.

    Leadership is for everyone, not just the well known people of the hobby. Quit waiting on the famous names to make it happen. Organize your local areas and state. Coordinate with your neighbors and host some interesting events. Think of your region and not just your state boundary.

    Finally I would really like to thank the hard working people that organized the 2008 events and the small, but dedicated core of campaigners that constantly participate in Ebufu events. Without you there would be no hobby. 2009 will be better. We have the right people now.
    Last edited by SCTiger; 10-22-2008, 03:02 PM.
    Gregory Deese
    Carolina Rifles-Living History Association

    http://www.carolinrifles.org
    "How can you call yourself a campaigner if you've never campaigned?"-Charles Heath, R. I. P.

  • #2
    Re: The End of Malaise 2008

    I started reenacting w/ a primarily N-S Skirmish group across the Indiana border in Illinois in 1959. Fell out of the activity w/ a change of professions 'bout 14 years ago. Am in the process of wading back in. If I may, a view from one long away from the hobby, which I impose upon no one. One problem, if problem there be, might be that generic 21st Century American phenomenon: nobody goes outside anymore. Hunting and fishing as sports are in decline, for instance. To prosper, reenacting must needs swim against this profound cultural shift to passive indoor activity. As a corollary, perhaps this is why many reenactors, otherwise painfully authentic, are now weight-challenged: being good Amurikans, reenacting is about all the arguably vigourous activity they bestir themselves to do. I mean no offense. One commentator on the Federal group photo recently posted on the forum observed that evidence the picture was authentic included the fact it would be difficult to collect that many thin reenactors today. Also a difference I note in reenacting now is a proliferation of small, sometime micro events. On the one hand, these grass roots events are a positive for several reasons, mostly living history w/in the range of area families, school groups, and the opportunity for what Mr. Deese (above) terms "campaigner/progressives" to immerse themselves among themselves in time-warp alternate reality. On the other hand, a plethora of small events do seem to suck vitality out of the substantial events of, say, 150 or more participants. Most of us can devote only so many weekends to the hobby and naturally want to support the near-to-home effort. Zora Arkus Duntov of Chevy Corvette fame once opined "there's no substitute for cubic inches" in engine power. Likewise, for squint-your-eyes-and-believe-you're-there, there's no substitute for boots on the ground.
    Last edited by David Fox; 10-22-2008, 04:01 PM.
    David Fox

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: The End of Malaise 2008

      I find your message very interesting, because we have the same phenomena, the causes and the effects of this part of the pond, in a lesser measure, certainly, but similar.
      I thus share your analysis and your conclusions and as we say about this part, " it is better to privilege the quality to the quantity "

      PS: I'am happy because, Malaise is a typically French word :)
      William Miconnet
      French Mess
      AES
      BGR & IPW Survivor
      Never ever give up!
      In memory of Steve Boulton, live the little story, lost in the history...
      I believe!

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: The End of Malaise 2008

        William,

        Not only is it French, but a word often associated with a certain peanut farmer that made Americus, GA, famous. That would be Jimmy Carter. I believe Gribble Deese was down that way a few days ago.

        Gribble,

        Yep, the same 300-350 people show up at event after event after event. It's that "who is us?" list come to life. CW reenacting is a helluva fun hobby. Some folks ought to get off the keyboards and get their collective arses to these fine events. Attendance....what a radical concept.

        I've had fun, how 'bout you?
        [B]Charles Heath[/B]
        [EMAIL="heath9999@aol.com"]heath9999@aol.com[/EMAIL]

        [URL="http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Spanglers_Spring_Living_History/"]12 - 14 Jun 09 Hoosiers at Gettysburg[/URL]

        [EMAIL="heath9999@aol.com"]17-19 Jul 09 Mumford/GCV Carpe Eventum [/EMAIL]

        [EMAIL="beatlefans1@verizon.net"]31 Jul - 2 Aug 09 Texans at Gettysburg [/EMAIL]

        [EMAIL="JDO@npmhu.org"] 11-13 Sep 09 Fortress Monroe [/EMAIL]

        [URL="http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Elmira_Death_March/?yguid=25647636"]2-4 Oct 09 Death March XI - Corduroy[/URL]

        [EMAIL="oldsoldier51@yahoo.com"] G'burg Memorial March [/EMAIL]

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: The End of Malaise 2008

          In regards to the French I had fun beau coup, it was good talking to you at Westville, between that and several other outstanding events, the excuses are over. If we can make it this year, we can make it any year.

          I really think the words "first person" scare the heck out of most reenactors more than period camping or accurate gear.
          It still shouldn't stop people from practicing the art.

          Thanks for the comments William and David. David if you aren't doing anything in early December, sign up for Fort Moultrie.
          Gregory Deese
          Carolina Rifles-Living History Association

          http://www.carolinrifles.org
          "How can you call yourself a campaigner if you've never campaigned?"-Charles Heath, R. I. P.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: The End of Malaise 2008

            Originally posted by SCTiger View Post
            David if you aren't doing anything in early December, sign up for Fort Moultrie.

            This looks like it should be a great event or series of events in one of my favorite forts. Keep it up.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: The End of Malaise 2008

              The best events I have attended keep folks busy in period activities appropriate to the scenario, i.e. picket duty, fatique duties, building breastworks, cooking, whatever else one can think of to keep the troops without much downtime. That can be exhausting, but ultimately much more satisfying. I think when you look back at the last year or two of very good events and some that are coming in 2009, that is and will be the common ingredient to a superior event.

              Neil Randolph
              1st WV

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: The End of Malaise 2008

                Pards,

                I for one am thinking positive toward the future of the hobby. One reason is that I'm investing lot's of $ toward improving my kit well enough to be able to participate in an EBUFU someday as Confederate mounted, (If there are any. Not much Cav info on this forum. Not complaining mind you.). Right now I'm gearing up and planning on attending an event next year hosted or at least greatly guided by T. Kern. After attending CC, my first and probably last, I was astonished at the negative responses in the Cav camps once I mentioned his name. While at times very outspoken,;) he is one of only a handful Confed Cav historians who are doing it at that level.
                I wondered at the numbers and camraderie at CC. After a bit of squinting, so as to try not to notice the bright shiney trim, women riders not bothering to conceal their gender, paint horses, hotdog and elephant ear stands, POV's among the horse camps, proliferation of camp furniture, flys, general carnival atmosphere, ect. I actually enjoyed myself. Thanks to CJ Daley being there, I also left with a lot less cash than I arrived with. BTW, that guy is a really nice person to take the time to answer all my ?s. The guys got a good heart and produces quality clothing, a real artist.
                My hats off to the "progressive/campaigner" movement. I hope this is a great part of the future of the hobby.

                Most sincerely,
                Brian Y. Mikels
                (New member in the hobby)
                [FONT="Book Antiqua"][SIZE="4"][B][FONT="Georgia"][SIZE="3"]Brian Y. Mikels[/SIZE][/FONT][/B][/SIZE][/FONT]

                [SIZE=3][FONT=Book Antiqua][B]"Das Paradies der Erde liegt auf den Rucken der Pferde."[/B][/FONT][/SIZE]

                [SIZE="2"][FONT="Book Antiqua"][B]"The Duck River Line-Winter 1863"[/B][/FONT][/SIZE] [FONT="Book Antiqua"][I]1, February 2009[/I][/FONT]
                [FONT="Book Antiqua"][I]Pvt. 2nd Tenn U.S. (Mounted Rifles)[/I][/FONT]
                [B][FONT="Book Antiqua"][SIZE=2][/SIZE]"The Fight for Crampton's Gap"[/FONT][/B] [I][FONT="Book Antiqua"]16-18, July 2010[/FONT][/I]
                [FONT="Book Antiqua"][I]Pvt. Devaney Good, 2nd Vir Cav[/I][/FONT]
                [B][FONT=Book Antiqua]"The 2015 Lincoln Funeral Coalition"[/FONT][/B] [I][FONT=Book Antiqua]1-3, May 2015[/FONT][/I]
                [FONT=Book Antiqua][I]Brig. Gen. James A. Ekin, Honor Guard[/I][/FONT]

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: The End of Malaise 2008

                  Mr Deese, I am glad to hear you are getting re-energized for next year. I would love to attend an event with you in 2009. :)

                  I am new and lucky enough that I was never affected by "The End of Malaise 2008" or even the beginning of it, heh. As I have mentioned on other topics, its all still "shiny" to me.

                  The events I have participated in this year, I have in my signature. They range from being on display at the Missouri State Fair to help out Missouri's DNR put on a crowd drawing attraction to Marmaduke's Raid-that took me a few days to fully recover from, and several various levels in between.

                  Its not the gear. Its not even the event itself. Its the people I have gotten to meet and hang with that make it shiny for me. Its all that I have learned on the road to becoming a better 'living historian' and not just an older fat guy in a civil war costume. Its the skills I have picked up like sewing and knowing I can get by just fine with only 1860's level tech on my back for a few days, and in most weather conditions. Its a lot of things that keep it interesting, and make me want to devote the money and time to this hobby.

                  But mainly, its the outstanding folks I have met, and what I have learned from them that keeps it shiny for me.
                  Ron Mueller
                  Illinois
                  New Madrid Guards

                  "How many legs does a dog have if you call the tail a leg?
                  Four. Calling a tail a leg doesn't make it a leg."
                  Abraham Lincoln

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X