Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Pocketknife Feedback

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Pocketknife Feedback

    Moderators feel free to move this post if it is not located correctly, I just want some informal feedback on a personal project.

    Greetings all,

    I have been an avid collector of pocketknives for 25 years, and have a collection that currently numbers over 750 knives from 100's of makers both old and new, with many CW vintage. So it was only natural for me to enter into the next phase and begin biulding my own knives. I solicit your feedback on my latest creation, I made this for myself to tote in my pocket at reenactments and living histories. I felt I could do a better job creating a period correct knife that represented a typical pocketknife of the 19th century than what is currently available on the commercial market, (at least as far as a good bone handled knife, Jim Kindred does offer an accurate wood handled knife). For the pattern I chose a very common and time tested two bladed swell end jack. meaning both blades pivot from the same bolster. The knife is somewhat of a forerunner to the trapper pattern but smaller, and totally correct for the period. For handles I used dyed jigged bone, I fancied dark green for some reason. In keeping with the period style, the bolsters are of German silver as are the pins and nails, linings are of brass. The blades are of carbon steel, one clip point and one spey blade, not the shiney stainless steel. The only 21st century liberties I took were to use cyrogenically treated blades, they have been quenched at -320 degrees F., this lines up the molecules so that they hold an unbelievable edge, I chose to do this as it is in no way detectable in the appearance and thus would not detract in visual appeal, but would certainly add in performance. Again in keeping with the period, you will note too the absence of any tang stamp. Most of the construction was done by hand using simple hand tools and bench work, but obviously some power machinery was used as well. All assembly and finishing was done by hand. While not overly large, she is a hefty little beast. Built solid and strong. Made here in the good old USA by yours truly, and built with my own hands to be the kind of knife that can be handed down to generations to come.
    I ask for your feedback as I am considering making a few for a few close comrades and perhaps in the future a very limited few for the the general masses. My next one will sport handles of natural undyed smooth bone. I'm also considering a three bladed equal end.

    You can see some pics here;







    Regards;

    Dan Houde
    Last edited by dahoude; 04-12-2004, 02:53 PM. Reason: updated
    Daniel A. Houde - Proprietor
    Orchard Hill Cutlery
    Website: http://www.orchardhillcutlery.com
    On Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/OrchardHillCutlery

    149th NYSV Co. B
    www.149thnewyork.com

    PM Cobleskill Lodge #394 F.& A.M.
    A.A.S.R. Valley of Schenectady
    Oneonta Chapter #277 R.A.M.


    "Uncal Sam has about as much care for his nefews as he has for his horses and mules" (Unidentified Union Soldier)

  • #2
    Re: Pocketknife Feedback

    While not anywhere near an expert on the subject (being a butcher's son I have a little knowledge on knives and such), I like the look of that knife. If you ever get them up for sale to the general masses, I'd buy one. Not enough people carry a good pocket knife.

    Regards,
    James K. Masson

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Pocketknife Feedback

      Thanks James, appreciate your feedback. I'm curious what others think because as I've tinkered with and built some nice bowies in the past, this is the first folder I've ever attempted. Thanks for your thoughts. Take care.

      Regards;

      Dan Houde
      Daniel A. Houde - Proprietor
      Orchard Hill Cutlery
      Website: http://www.orchardhillcutlery.com
      On Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/OrchardHillCutlery

      149th NYSV Co. B
      www.149thnewyork.com

      PM Cobleskill Lodge #394 F.& A.M.
      A.A.S.R. Valley of Schenectady
      Oneonta Chapter #277 R.A.M.


      "Uncal Sam has about as much care for his nefews as he has for his horses and mules" (Unidentified Union Soldier)

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Pocketknife Feedback

        All ahead full Mr Houde! We need 'em. Always looking for interesting new "rope wrenches" myself.

        Cordially,

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Pocketknife Feedback

          Mr. Houde,

          I'm just curious, what would I be looking to spend on this knife? I REALLY like the look of it and the more and more I look at those pictures, the more and more I want one.

          Regards,
          James K. Masson

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Pocketknife Feedback

            It looks beautiful to me, I'd certainly carry it around with me even when I'm not in the field. I'd also like to see it go into production.
            Phil Graf

            Can't some of our good friends send us some tobacco? We intend to "hang up our stockings." if they can't send tobacco, please send us the seed, and we will commence preparing the ground; for we mean to defend this place till h-ll freezes over, and then fight the Yankees on the ice.

            Private Co. A, Cook's Reg't, Galveston Island.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Pocketknife Feedback

              Mr. Bartsch,

              Much appreciated, perhaps in the future, I need to "hone" my skills some more (no pune intended) :wink_smil.

              Mr. Masson,

              I'm very flattered by your interest, as to what I would charge I'm not really sure, I'm not really at that point yet, right now I'm just enjoying tinkering around. When I choose to make some to sell outright you'll be the first I contact.

              Here are a few more pics;





              Daniel A. Houde - Proprietor
              Orchard Hill Cutlery
              Website: http://www.orchardhillcutlery.com
              On Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/OrchardHillCutlery

              149th NYSV Co. B
              www.149thnewyork.com

              PM Cobleskill Lodge #394 F.& A.M.
              A.A.S.R. Valley of Schenectady
              Oneonta Chapter #277 R.A.M.


              "Uncal Sam has about as much care for his nefews as he has for his horses and mules" (Unidentified Union Soldier)

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Pocketknife Feedback

                I am also very interested. It does show a period style. I too would look forward to carry one of those! I would agree that you should keep making them.
                I am, Yr. Ob't Servant,
                Riley Ewen

                VMI CLASS OF 2012
                Hard Head Mess
                Prodigal Sons Mess, Co. B 36th Illinois Infantry
                Old Northwest Volunteers

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Pocketknife Feedback

                  Mr Houde, in my humble opinion, you could not make them quick enough to satisfy the demand that will be created when folks see these photos. Very cool knife. I especially like the fact it has the two blades. Very useful. I may have to have a couple of these. Please put me on the list.

                  Sam Doolin

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Pocketknife Feedback

                    Would you be willing to make other period style variations?

                    I gotta have one, I would carry it everyday.
                    Robert Johnson

                    "Them fellers out thar you ar goin up against, ain't none of the blue-bellied, white-livered Yanks and sassidge-eatin'forrin' hirelin's you have in Virginny that run atthe snap of a cap - they're Western fellers, an' they'll mighty quick give you a bellyful o' fightin."



                    In memory of: William Garry Co.H 5th USCC KIA 10/2/64 Saltville VA.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Pocketknife Feedback

                      Dan,

                      Looks like a good tight knife from the images. The ultimate test would be a little slicing, dicing and gutting, but it looks like it may fare well in that area.

                      If you make one...I would buy one. Might be a good birthday present for Ericka to get me....when they are available.

                      I would think that this would be another top item for you through the sutlery. I think they would surpass the Canteens with little effort.

                      Reguards,
                      Todd Morris

                      Proprietor, Morris & Company Historical Clothiers

                      http://morrisclothiers.com

                      Canton Lodge #60 F&AM Canton, Ohio


                      In Memorium: Pvt. Simon Morris, Co. G, 78th OVI Died: April 14, 1863 Jefferson Barracks, Missouri
                      Joseph Rezin Thompson, 1st W.Va. Light Artillery
                      Azville W. Lindsey, Co. G, 12th W.Va. Volunteer Infantry

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Pocketknife Feedback

                        I also would be interested in a period knife, with a high-quality blade such as this has. The repos currently available seem to have blades of questionable quality and edge-holding ability. I'd get in line for one.

                        Doug Price

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Pocketknife Feedback

                          Mr. Houde, I am very interested in obtaining one like in the photos. It just so happens i was looking to upgrade the one from my kit.
                          ;) Rich Pisarski
                          119th NY Vol.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Pocketknife Feedback

                            Umm damn!.. I would really enjoy one of those. I am sure it take several hours of your labor to make something nice as this. I am sure the jonah in me would enjoy sliceing a finger while breaking something like this in :tounge_sm

                            keep us posted
                            [SIZE=2][B]Mark Mason[/B][/SIZE] :cool:
                            [SIZE=2][I]Tar Water Mess[/I][/SIZE]
                            [SIZE=2][I]GHTI[/I][/SIZE]
                            [URL]http://http://www.ghti.homestead.com/[/URL]

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Pocketknife Feedback

                              Yet another one, count me in!

                              :tounge_sm ]
                              Mark Hoffman
                              Hoecake Mess

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X