Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...



    'Is the memory of these things viable?' re-enactor asks

    Robert Lee Hodge, the poster boy for hard-core Civil War buffs, is still fighting for accuracy.

    BY BENTLEY BOYD
    342-8812

    July 29, 2007

    He became the face of a new breed of re-enactor - a scowling, dirty face staring out from the cover of a 1998 best-seller by Pulitzer Prize winner Tony Horwitz.

    Robert Lee Hodge holds a menacing blade on the cover of "Confederates in the Attic." He has long, bushy chin whiskers. And you can be sure that his buttons are accurate - even if he had to urinate on them to get the right corrosion effect.

    "When the Horwitz book came out, I was a Civil War bohemian," he said. "I was waiting tables just to get enough money to buy Civil War gear."

    Living History is Hodge's lifelong pursuit: Hodge's father came from Alabama and named his son for Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee when Hodge was born on Gen. Stonewall Jackson's birthday. Hodge cut grass as a kid to get money for gear. He wore a Confederate kepi hat in his first-grade photo.

    Many people join the re-enacting hobby because of family connections to past events, but Hodge became famous for deriding half-baked hobbyists. The Horwitz book spread his use of the word "farb" for re-enactors who wore wristwatches or used sunscreen or smoked cigarettes.

    Hodge and his buddies were "super hard-core" for spending the night sleeping on the ground in the spooning position to keep warm - or for practicing how to look dead and bloated like the figures in Mathew Brady Civil War photos do.

    "The book has always been a love/hate thing for me. I don't want to be known as the guy who mimics bloody corpses and urinates on his buttons," said Hodge, who lives in Sterling. "Some people in the re-enactment world really hate that book. I've gotten a lot of flak for the antics that the book publicized."

    Nearly 10 years after the book's publication, he's still asked for autographs, but he's distancing himself. He doesn't do many re-enactments for fun anymore. Hodge was in Gettysburg, Pa., in the first week of July - not to re-create 1863's pivotal battle of the Civil War but to visit old re-enactor buddies and hang out at an inn, listening to Civil War music.

    Hodge notes he was only 28 when Horwitz was doing his book research. "I'm 40 now," he said. "I pride myself at still being a kid at heart, but I also have to look at doing things that are important. Time becomes a great enemy. It's fleeting. Things change. There are books I want to get written and videos I want to do. There's a sense of urgency, a sense of mission."

    Now he's one-third of the ownership of Wide Awake Films and is filming the story of a Jesse James bank robbery in Kansas City, Mo. He still has a dark, bushy beard, so he can appear in front of the camera when needed.

    "It's a struggle in perpetuity for the minds of the people. Is the memory of these things viable?" he asked. "You're up against the shallow and superficial and meaningless search for a short-term chuckle or the adulation of a professional sports team. You're competing with 'American Idol' and 'Survivor.' "

    Wide Awake has made "The Battle of Spotsylvania" and "The Battle of Franklin: Five Hours in the Valley of Death," which won a regional Emmy for Best Historical Documentary.

    "I'd like to turn on a lot of kids to this who haven't been turned on to it before, through visuals and through colorful stories of these people," he said.

    "People tend to think of people in the past as less intelligent. These people weren't cavemen. They weren't Cro-Mags (Cro-Magnons). When you look at their written words, I look at them as giants. We are pygmies, compared to what they endured."

    Hodge visited Endview Plantation in Newport News in April with the Civil War Preservation Trust. He serves on the board of directors for several preservation organizations and writes a preservation column for a magazine, America's Civil War. Hodge has appeared on National Public Radio and the front page of The Wall Street Journal, and he worked on the series "Civil War Journal" that appeared on The History Channel. He worked on several Civil War volumes for Time-Life Books.

    He remains passionate. He says anyone who doesn't recognize the civil rights effort that happened in the decade after the Civil War is "ignorant and shallow."

    His eye now is on 2011, the 150th anniversary of the start of the Civil War. He thinks that the centennial commemoration in the 1960s fell flat because American society got distracted by the assassination of President John F. Kennedy and the Vietnam War.

    He's happy that Virginia has a committee planning now for 2011, but he calls the federal government's planning "underwhelming."

    He said, "Do we value these things? I'm not convinced we do. I'm not convinced we don't. It's up to the kids. It's going to be up to generations I'll never meet."

    Copyright © 2007, Newport News, Va., Daily Press
    Fred D. Taylor
    Co. G, Portsmouth Rifles
    9th Virginia Infantry

  • #2
    Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

    Fred,

    Thanks for passing this along.
    [FONT=Georgia][/FONT][SIZE="3"][FONT="Georgia"]Dan Biggs[/FONT][/SIZE]


    -Member of the Southwest Volunteers Mess

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

      Originally posted by western reb View Post
      Fred,

      Thanks for passing this along.
      Again Thanks
      [FONT="Georgia"][/FONT] Aaron Bolis
      1st. co. Richmond Howitzers

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

        Very interesting article Mr. Taylor I enjoyed reading it
        [B][FONT="Georgia"][I]P. L. Parault[/I][/FONT][/B][FONT="Book Antiqua"][/FONT]

        [I][B]"Three score and ten I can remember well, within the volume of which time I have seen hours dreadful and things strange: but this sore night hath trifled former knowings."

        William Shakespeare[/B][/I]

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

          Hallo!

          "Hodge and his buddies were "super hard-core" for spending the night sleeping on the ground in the spooning position to keep warm - or for practicing how to look dead and bloated like the figures in Mathew Brady Civil War photos do."

          IMHO, it is amazing how this gets regurgitated, er resurrected, every so often.
          Sigh..

          Sorry. As an aspiring wannabe "super hard-core" myself, I can't finish that thought as I am off to Dead and Bloated Practice" and my bladder needs emptying.
          (Where are those buttons?)

          Curt
          Curt Schmidt
          In gleichem Schritt und Tritt, Curt Schmidt

          -Hard and sharp as flint...secret, and self-contained, and solitary as an oyster.
          -Haplogroup R1b M343 (Subclade R1b1a2 M269)
          -Pointless Folksy Wisdom Mess, Oblio Lodge #1
          -Vastly Ignorant
          -Often incorrect, technically, historically, factually.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

            Urinating on buttons?

            That's a rather novel approach to add patina to an item.
            Must one drink a bellyfull of acidic beverages to achieve the desired effect?

            Seriously folks, I've found that good old gunpowder residue will tarnish brass in a hurry. And the aroma is not nearly as offensive.

            YMHS
            Wendell Brown
            Wendell Brown

            Citizen Gaurd, The Orphan Brigade. N-SSA

            HERE'D YOUR MULE

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

              Seriously, have fun trying to pass inspection.
              Scott Gulley
              PPM/GHTI/WIG

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

                Hallo!

                Seriously folks, I've found that good old campfire ash and water made into a paste will untarnish brass in a hurry. And the aroma is not nearly as offensive.

                ;) :) :)

                Curt
                Curt Schmidt
                In gleichem Schritt und Tritt, Curt Schmidt

                -Hard and sharp as flint...secret, and self-contained, and solitary as an oyster.
                -Haplogroup R1b M343 (Subclade R1b1a2 M269)
                -Pointless Folksy Wisdom Mess, Oblio Lodge #1
                -Vastly Ignorant
                -Often incorrect, technically, historically, factually.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

                  Ummm... I'm still wondering why one would want their buttons to be tarnished?

                  Why would want their buttons to look antique, or old... or tarnished?

                  Weren't the men in the 1860's wearing uniforms with newer buttons? Weren't they in military organizations in which they were periodically inspected? Wasn't part of those inspections a look at their uniforms (and subsequently... buttons)? Aren't there period references to the men having to work on looking good for these inspections?

                  Perhaps some of the 'legendary hardcore stuff' written about in Horowitz's (in)famous book, were a bit written with a bent towards being controversial, vice being realistic in order to make the book more commercial (such as was done with Swafford's book about the 1st Gulf War Jarhead).
                  Brian Hicks
                  Widows' Sons Mess

                  Known lately to associate with the WIG and the Armory Guards

                  "He's a good enough fellow... but I fear he may be another Alcibiades."

                  “Every man ever got a statue made of him was one kinda sumbitch or another. It ain’t about you. It’s about what THEY need.”CAPTAIN MALCOLM REYNOLDS

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

                    "Ummm... I'm still wondering why one would want their buttons to be tarnished?"

                    Because they have never met real life Master Sgt/WIG Sgt Major Brian Hicks? "Why do you're buttons look like that!"
                    Patrick Landrum
                    Independent Rifles

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

                      a little wood ash and spit will polish them buttons right up nicely and pass inspection of grumpy old nco's who ain't had their morning coffee(or what other beverage they have in the morning).:)
                      Tom Yearby
                      Texas Ground Hornets

                      "I'd rather shoot a man than a snake." Robert Stumbling Bear

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

                        I find it rare to attend an event where someone isn't polishing their brass, and to add to this sweet goodness of soldiering, most of the folks reading this have been to events where they were issued a variety of brass polishing agents. This could lead to a fun discussion about gilded buttons of the period, but I digress. I'll leave that to the relic hunters.

                        I recall a number of people who soaked their buttons in urine. I also asked if they removed the laquer coating first.
                        [B]Charles Heath[/B]
                        [EMAIL="heath9999@aol.com"]heath9999@aol.com[/EMAIL]

                        [URL="http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Spanglers_Spring_Living_History/"]12 - 14 Jun 09 Hoosiers at Gettysburg[/URL]

                        [EMAIL="heath9999@aol.com"]17-19 Jul 09 Mumford/GCV Carpe Eventum [/EMAIL]

                        [EMAIL="beatlefans1@verizon.net"]31 Jul - 2 Aug 09 Texans at Gettysburg [/EMAIL]

                        [EMAIL="JDO@npmhu.org"] 11-13 Sep 09 Fortress Monroe [/EMAIL]

                        [URL="http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Elmira_Death_March/?yguid=25647636"]2-4 Oct 09 Death March XI - Corduroy[/URL]

                        [EMAIL="oldsoldier51@yahoo.com"] G'burg Memorial March [/EMAIL]

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

                          It's my understanding that Horowitz took liberties in his book. The mental image of some dude pissing on his buttons obviously still resonates today as that is what is addressed here rather than the exceedingly positive impact Rob Hodge has had on the hobby and the preservation effort at large. I'm lucky enough to have hung out with Rob on several occasions (I wish it could be more but I'm in CA. now) and call him a friend to this day.

                          I've always been tremendously respectful of his passion and the fact that he has the balls to get up and do something about it. That he is able to do that is the reason that he's been able to enter into the national level. He and a few other folks have absolutely inspired me to follow my passion no matter how nuts it might seem and as a result I've found a job that I love with possibilities of branching out into projects that may one day contribute to battlefield preservation on a level I could not accomplish personally.

                          Hodge has worked hard for what he has today and he's also done a lot of selfless acts to get there. I'm proud I can call him a friend.

                          Andrew
                          Andrew Quist
                          Director, Old Oak Ranch Educational Programs
                          www.oldoak.com/goldcamp.html


                          ".. . let no man, unchallenged, asperse the memory of our sacred dead, our fallen comrades, with the charge of treason and rebellion. They fell in defense of the liberty and independence of their country, consequently were heroes and patriots."

                          - General George W. Gordon, Army of Tennessee

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

                            I know when Sgt. Hicks is my inspecting NCO that I will make sure to prepare a good 20 minutes cleaning up the musket, dust off jacket/trousers and will present my gear appropriately on my person. There is a weird mentality of guys that like their equipment to look relic, they see the items in the museum and they try to replicate that look as it is with 140 years of being tossed around from one person to the next in many different environments.

                            To defend Hodge though, I will have to admit that I read that book when it came out and little else about the book had my attention quite like the Southern Guard stories in that book. I was a seriuos reenactor kid at the time, but a farby one at that.......the book made me understand that although i'm not all for bloating or urinating on my stuff, I did share the same mindset and immediately realized I had to change EVERYTHING about what I was doing and how I was doing it. Not only me, several others have been inspired by that book to start progressing because Hodge gives you soo many good reasons WHY to do it throughout the book. It is what it is, a controversial, goofy kind of book........but these things can inspire people. I know that most people tend to be annoyed by ONE person being so over hyped and blown out of proportion. He isn't a walking god, but he isn't a nobody and he did have incredible impressions in his day. I like guys who go out of their way in their normal lives to portray their living history impressions better (collecting the right gear/weapons, body trim , hair, etc).

                            Just my nobody opinion.
                            Preston Todd
                            Hard Case Boys
                            Top Rail Mess

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: 'Is the memory of these things viable?' reenactor asks...

                              Gentlemen,

                              Not that anyone wants my 3.5 cent opinion here, but I think it's all sort of sad. I mean, here a guy is talked about and known most for whizzing on his buttons instead of his work of trying to get history in front of the public eye. No, I didn't read the book. I had it, some of my family read it, but I prefer to read books 1870 or earlier for my amusement and spare time. As I said, I don't know the man, never met him and unlikely will have that opportunity, however, it's odd to hear people condemn other's so quickly. Yes, the whizzing button thing does make him sound like a crackpot, but simply because that was suggested here in the forum doesn't mean that is all to his life and ALL that we should think of someone for. Some friends of mine loved the book, others hated it passionately, but that is their opinion and praise be that we are allowed to think as we like, say what we feel, and choose our own friends in society.
                              The only thing that concerns me is that the world doesn't judge the rest of us LH folks with the idea that we all pee on our clothes. Is he a Different drummer? Sure, but that doesn't mean that I am like him. I may be just as different since we've done period food preparation by dipping our fresh eggs in gum arabic and then rolling them in charcoal and waiting to see how they keep....sometimes period recipes and things done in the past are only learned through experience. BTW, the eggs worked out fine.
                              But I'm convinced that if your uniform is new, your buttons should be too, besides, no gentleman would want to look like a bum so polish those buttons. I dunno, actions speak louder than words so I think it best to see what the man does, rather than what I hear.
                              Mfr,
                              Judith Peebles.
                              No Wooden Nutmegs Sold Here.
                              [B]Books![B][/B][/B] The Original Search Engine.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X