Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Monacacy Trash Incinerator seems to be back "ON"

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Monacacy Trash Incinerator seems to be back "ON"

    I found this posted on Civil War historian Eric Whittenburg's blog by Mike Clem (original post is at http://civilwarcavalry.com/?p=1593#comments):

    Mike Clem // Jun 26, 2009 at 6:08 pm
    As if this decision wasn’t enough of a blow to battlefield preservation, the Frederick County, Md., Commissioners landed another sucker punch this same week to the site of the “Battle That Saved Washington.”

    In late April the five-member board suspended deliberations on building a trash incinerator at a county site across the Monocacy River from the battlefield in search of waste disposal alternatives. But this month Commissioner Charles Jenkins moved to reconsider the plan and in a 3-2 vote on Tuesday, the board approved construction of the $512 million plant literally within yards of the Worthington-McKinney Ford used by McCausland’s cavalry brigade and later Gordon’s division to outflank Lew Wallace’s handful of federals blocking Jubal Early’s drive down the Georgetown Pike to Washington.

    (See story at http://www.fredericknewspost.com/sec...?StoryID=91817)

    Not only will the garbage-burning plant sit within the designated National Historic Landmark boundary for the battlefield, but the 350-foot smokestack and 100-foot tall facility will dominate the skyline from any point in the park. Then there’s the constant traffic, noise, lights and odor produced by the plant’s 24-hour operation required to incinerate 1,500 tons of trash seven days week that will confront the park’s visitors.

    Superintendent Susan Trail said that since 2000, the park expenditures total about $4.5 million to stabilize historic buildings, rehabilitate the battlefield landscape and remove non-historic structures. An additional $4 million was spent for its new visitor center, which opened last June. Trail said visitation last year was 22,225, up from 18,579 in 2006. The park is projecting about 30,000 visitors this year.

    A recent independent survey conducted by Michigan State University on the economic impact of the park found that the total contribution to the local economy in 2006 was 35 jobs and $2.1 million in added value — before the new visitor’s center opened.

    Even if the commissioners are so cold-bloodedly callous and uncaring about the destruction of our nation’s historic sites and dishonoring the 2,300 Americans who made the river run red with their blood on that hot July day in 1864, you’d think in this economic climate they’d be more sensitive to protecting a revenue-producing major tourist attraction that was funded by our tax dollars!

    I hope you can use your bully pulpit to help make fellow preservationists aware of this desecration and urge your many readers to contact the Frederick Board of County Commissioners about this outrageous desecration, especially “Flip-Flop Charlie” Jenkins (chjenkins@fredco-md.net) and his colleagues John L. “Lennie” Thompson (lthompson@fredco-md.net) and Vice President David Gray (dgray@fredco-md.net) who voted for the incinerator. Board President Jan Gardner (jgardner@fredco-md.net) opposes the location and Kai Hagen (khagen@fredco-md.net) is against the entire project. They can also be reached at Winchester Hall, 12 East Church St., Frederick, MD 21701, phone: (301) 600-9000; fax: (301) 600-1849; web site: http://www.co.frederick.md.us/index.aspx?NID=27

    I apologize for my verbosity and for standing on your soapbox to make my speech, but I know you have a soft spot for this small, little remembered field that’s overshadowed by its more famous Civil War neighbors at nearby Gettysburg and Antietam. Thank you for your support to save the site of the Battle That Saved Washington.

    -----------------------END QUOTED TEXT-------------------------
    Sincerely,
    Emmanuel Dabney
    Atlantic Guard Soldiers' Aid Society
    http://www.agsas.org

    "God hasten the day when war shall cease, when slavery shall be blotted from the face of the earth, and when, instead of destruction and desolation, peace, prosperity, liberty, and virtue shall rule the earth!"--John C. Brock, Commissary Sergeant, 43d United States Colored Troops

  • #2
    Re: Monacacy Trash Incinerator seems to be back "ON"

    The county's Planning Commission determined plans to build a waste-to-energy plant weren't consistent with the county's comprehensive plan, a document that gives a 20-year look at how the county should grow and develop.

    Planning Commission members argued that the proposed plant's smokestack, and its proximity to both the Monocacy Scenic River and the Monocacy National Battlefield, were inconsistent with county goals for historic preservation and creating a river buffer.

    "The battlefield is going to be impacted in a large way, it's a grave concern to me," said Planning Commission member Joseph F. Brown III.

    The Planning Commission's move blocks Frederick County Commissioners from changing the Solid Waste Management Plan, a document that must conform with waste-to-energy in order for the plant to be built.

    The plant and plan must conform to receive a permit from the Maryland Department of the Environment.

    County commissioners, who voted to build the waste-to-energy plant, criticized the Planning Commission for its vote.

    Commissioner Charles Jenkins called it irresponsible, and criticized planning commission members for not making their reasoning clear.

    Gardner said she didn't believe it was consistent with the law, and she and other commissioners criticized planning commission members who abstained from voting.

    The vote to find it inconsistent was 3-2, with two abstentions. That means only three out of seven planning commissioners voted for the successful motion.

    "I think they have very confusing rules, and they make some of it up as they go," Gardner said.

    As it stands, the commissioners have a few different options to circumvent or reverse the Planning Commission's ruling.

    County commissioners discussed four options Thursday, but have not settled on a course of action.

    Those include:

    n Deleting the sections of the comprehensive plan that the Planning Commission found inconsistent.

    "We could delete all these sections from the comp plan, and then what's the basis of their decision?" Commissioners President Jan Gardner said.

    Those sections include broad goals like "Frederick County strongly encourages (that) the design of new signs, buildings and subdivisions not conflict with existing historic structures and settlements" and more specific ones like, "The county shall establish a 500-foot development setback/buffer area along the Monocacy Scenic River."

    n Appealing the Planning Commission's decision. The appeal would need to be lodged within 30 days, and then the matter would go to court.

    n Deciding that the project conforms to the solid waste management plan as currently written. Such a move would mean the Planning Commission would not have to weigh in.

    County Attorney John Mathias said he was "pretty sure" county commissioners would have to make the decision to rule that the plans conform.

    n Adding language to the comprehensive plan, making it impossible for the Planning Commission to declare it inconsistent. Such language could include strong support for waste-to-energy.

    Drew

    "God knows, as many posts as go up on this site everyday, there's plenty of folks who know how to type. Put those keyboards to work on a real issue that's tied to the history that we love and obsess over so much." F.B.

    "...mow hay, cut wood, prepare great food, drink schwitzel, knit, sew, spin wool, rock out to a good pinch of snuff and somehow still find time to go fly a kite." N.B.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Monacacy Trash Incinerator seems to be back "ON"

      FREDERICK, Md. - The Frederick County Planning Commission just put a halt on plans for a controversial incinerator. They say it would clash with the county's commitment to environmental and historic preservation but the proposal isn't dead yet.

      Members of the Frederick County Planning Commission say they couldn't approve the incinerator because it would directly contradict the county's comprehensive plan.

      More than two-and-a-half years ago, Frederick County officials introduced a plan for the 800 tons of garbage residents produce each day. They would build a $500 million waste-to-energy incinerator preserving landfill space and generating energy.

      "A lot of people in Frederick city are not happy with it being the entrance to Frederick city," said Lisa Baugher, community leader and candidate for Maryland State Senate.

      The hold-up occurred because the proposed construction site is adjacent to two of Frederick County's most cherished resources: the Monocacy River and the Monocacy National Battlefield.

      Baugher says she doesn't understand why the state is spending $25 million to clean up the Chesapeake Bay if it's going to drop a waste treatment plant right on top of the watershed.

      "The location near a tributary seems counterproductive to the efforts that Maryland's been taking for years," she said.

      But County Commissioner David Gray says Frederick residents need a long-term solution for their trash. "We have to have something that's going to deal with this -- we take 800 tons of trash every day," he said.

      Gray insists the emission controls would be unprecedented. "I believe these emission levels will be the tightest emission levels in the entire world," he said.

      Right now, the commissioners are looking at a couple of options for how to proceed. They could appeal and take the matter to court, or they could revise the language in the county's comprehensive plan. Sources say that the revision of rhetoric is most likely at this point.

      WJLA is the local ABC affiliate for the greater Washington DC area. From our studios in Arlington, VA ABC7 covers national and local news, sports, weather, traffic and culture and carries entertainment and sports programming. WJLA serves Alexandria, Springfield, Annandale, Tysons, Reston, Ashburn, Centreville and Manassas, Virginia and Bethesda, Rockville, Gaithersburg, Silver Spring, Wheaton, Beltsville, Greenbelt, Bowie, College Park, Largo, Crofton, Annapolis, Hyattsville and Takoma Park, Maryland, and all the communities in between.
      Drew

      "God knows, as many posts as go up on this site everyday, there's plenty of folks who know how to type. Put those keyboards to work on a real issue that's tied to the history that we love and obsess over so much." F.B.

      "...mow hay, cut wood, prepare great food, drink schwitzel, knit, sew, spin wool, rock out to a good pinch of snuff and somehow still find time to go fly a kite." N.B.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Monacacy Trash Incinerator seems to be back "ON"

        As property becomes as valuable in other areas along the east coast as it has gotten in parts of New England, thus making landfills hideously expensive, people will start to realize that curbside recycling will have to be a part of the equation to disposing of their stuff. Too bad the folks at Frederick can't be a bit more fore-sighted considering the negative impact on the battlefield this would be if it finally does go through!
        [FONT=Trebuchet MS]Joanna Norris Forbes[/FONT]

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Monacacy Trash Incinerator seems to be back "ON"

          This is very disconcerting. I visited Monocacy this past weekend and was very impressed with the new visitor center on the north side of the river and new interpretive trails around the park, including the Best Farm site.

          Todd Berkoff
          Todd S. Berkoff

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Monacacy Trash Incinerator seems to be back "ON"

            Maryland state Sen. Alex Mooney says he's renewing his fight against a proposed regional trash incinerator near Frederick.

            The Frederick County Republican said Wednesday he is introducing two bills aimed at blocking construction of the $500 million project in an industrial park near the Monocacy National Battlefield.

            One bill would prohibit incinerators within three miles any home, church, school, park or hospital.

            The other would ban incinerators within a mile of national parks, including the Civil War battlefield.

            Mooney says he wants the incinerator out of his district. He says that if it's built anywhere, it should be in a heavy industrial area.

            Mooney tried and failed to block the project in last year's General Assembly.

            Drew

            "God knows, as many posts as go up on this site everyday, there's plenty of folks who know how to type. Put those keyboards to work on a real issue that's tied to the history that we love and obsess over so much." F.B.

            "...mow hay, cut wood, prepare great food, drink schwitzel, knit, sew, spin wool, rock out to a good pinch of snuff and somehow still find time to go fly a kite." N.B.

            Comment

            Working...
            X